Figures UK Accountancy

News · HMRC

HMRC Said No to 41% of Requests for Clarity. Here's What That Means for You

Ever asked a straight question and got a straight "no"? New figures show it's happening more than at any point in the last five years.

Illustration of a worried business owner at a desk with a rejected cross and question mark

Quick answer

HMRC rejected 715 of 1,741 requests for clarity on tax rules in 2025-26. That's 41%, up from 34% the year before and the highest rate in five years. When HMRC won't confirm how a rule applies, you need an adviser who will help you work it out.

Tax is complicated enough without the tax authority declining to tell you how its own rules work. Yet according to figures reported by The Daily Telegraph, that is increasingly what's happening.

The numbers

1,741

requests for clarity made in 2025-26

715

turned down by HMRC

41%

rejection rate, up from 34% in 2024-25

In plain English: roughly four in every ten times someone asked HMRC to confirm how a tax rule applies to their situation, HMRC declined to give that confirmation. It's the highest rejection rate in five years.

What the experts are saying

Elizabeth Bradley of law firm BCLP said that without confirmation from HMRC, taxpayers feel "more exposed". That makes sense: if you can't be sure how HMRC will read a rule, you're making decisions with a little less certainty than you'd like.

Tim Stovold of Moore Kingston Smith noted that HMRC aims to discourage easy queries when guidance is already available. In other words, HMRC wants people to check its published guidance before they ask.

An HMRC spokesman explained that many rejections happen because requests are seeking reassurance rather than clarity. Put simply, HMRC says some people are asking it to bless a decision rather than explain a rule.

Both things can be true. HMRC has a fair point that its guidance answers many questions. But where your situation falls into a grey area, "check the guidance" doesn't always help, and a rising number of "no" answers leaves people on their own.

What does this mean for a small business?

The formal clarity process is more often used by advisers acting for larger clients. But the knock-on effect is felt across the board. Whenever the rules aren't clear and HMRC won't weigh in, the risk shifts onto the taxpayer. For a business owner, that can mean:

  • Making a decision on VAT, CIS, payroll or director's pay without being certain how it will be treated.
  • Finding out later that HMRC reads a rule differently, sometimes with interest or penalties attached.
  • Spending time and money untangling a problem that early advice could have avoided.

How to protect yourself

  1. Start with HMRC's published guidance. If the answer is there, you're on solid ground. Keep a note of what you read and when.
  2. Ask before you act. If you're unsure, talk to your accountant before the transaction, not after the return is filed.
  3. Keep clear records. Good bookkeeping is your best evidence if HMRC ever asks why you took a particular position.
  4. Don't wait for year-end. Grey areas are easier to deal with as they come up than in a rush before a deadline.

Not sure how a tax rule applies to you?

Ask us. Unlimited advice is included in your fixed monthly fee, so there's no meter running when you pick up the phone.

Why monthly support matters

When HMRC won't give you a straight answer, the next best thing is an accountant who knows your business and is on hand throughout the year. Our team of six are all Xero certified, AML trained and Dext certified, and we work with our clients every month, not just at year-end. That means questions get answered as they arise, using your up-to-date figures, rather than after the event.

Frequently asked questions

What is a request for clarity from HMRC?

It's when a taxpayer or their adviser asks HMRC to confirm how it reads a particular tax rule, usually before they go ahead with a transaction or decision. A confirmation gives welcome certainty about how the rules will be applied.

Does this mean HMRC's guidance can't be trusted?

No. HMRC's published guidance is the right starting point, and many queries are answered there. The issue is what happens when your situation isn't covered clearly and HMRC declines to confirm its view.

Does this affect ordinary small businesses and sole traders?

The figures relate to formal requests for clarity, which are more often made by advisers on behalf of clients. But the effect is felt everywhere: if the rules are grey and HMRC won't weigh in, you need someone who can interpret them carefully for your situation.

What should I do if I'm unsure how a tax rule applies to me?

Check HMRC's published guidance first, keep a record of what you relied on, and speak to your accountant before acting. Getting advice early is far cheaper than fixing a problem afterwards.

Source: The Daily Telegraph, reporting on HMRC figures for 2025-26, including comments from Elizabeth Bradley (BCLP), Tim Stovold (Moore Kingston Smith) and an HMRC spokesman.

This article is for general information only and isn't personal advice. Please speak to us about your own circumstances.

Get In Touch

Get In Touch With Us

Want a fixed monthly quote or a quick chat about switching accountants? Send us a message — we'll reply with clear next steps.

Worried about switching? Don't be.

You can move to Figures UK at any point in the year — no need to wait for year end. We handle the entire handover, including moving your records and transferring everything to HMRC, so the switch is seamless and stress-free for you.

By submitting this form you agree that Figures UK can contact you by the email address and telephone number provided above.

Or call us directly:

01778 252712

You can also PM us directly — we're always happy to chat.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

ChatChat