Skip to main content

Should You File Your Taxes Yourself or Hire an Accountant?


The annual ritual of filing taxes can be a daunting task for many individuals. The complexity of tax laws, the fear of making errors, and the time-consuming nature of the process often leave people wondering whether they should tackle their taxes on their own or seek the assistance of a professional accountant. While there is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question, considering various factors can help you make an informed decision that aligns with your specific circumstances. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of filing taxes yourself versus hiring an accountant, enabling you to determine the best approach for your tax preparation.

Filing Taxes Yourself: Pros and Cons

Cost Savings: One of the most obvious benefits of filing taxes yourself is the potential for cost savings. Hiring an accountant is an investment, by taking on the task yourself, you can avoid the fees associated with professional tax preparation.


Learning Opportunity: Preparing your taxes can provide a valuable learning experience. It forces you to understand tax laws, forms, and deductions, increasing your understanding of your financial situation and potential tax benefits. This knowledge can empower you to make better financial decisions for your business in the future.


Control and Independence: Filing your taxes yourself gives you complete control over the process. You can ensure that all relevant information is accurately included, and you have a comprehensive understanding of your tax return.


Limited Complexity: For individuals with uncomplicated tax situations, such as those with a single source of income, few deductions, and no significant investments or business ventures, filing taxes yourself can be relatively straightforward. With readily available tax software and online resources, the process can be simplified, making it more manageable for the average taxpayer.


However, there are also potential drawbacks to filing taxes yourself, that do need to be seriously considered:


Time-Consuming: Tax preparation requires time and effort, especially if you are not familiar with the process. Gathering all necessary documents, filling out the relevant forms, and ensuring total accuracy can be time-consuming, particularly as your financial situation becomes more complex as your business grows.


Limited Expertise: Tax laws are intricate and subject to frequent changes. Without a deep understanding of these laws and regulations, you may miss out on potential deductions or credits. Additionally, you may end up making mistakes that could trigger audits or result in penalties.


Risk of Errors: Filing taxes incorrectly can lead to serious consequences, including fines, interest charges, and delayed refunds. The complexity of tax codes, combined with the potential for oversight or misinterpretation, increases the risk of errors when filing taxes without professional guidance.


Hiring an Accountant: Pros and Cons

Now, let’s consider the advantages and disadvantages of hiring an accountant to handle your tax preparation:


Expert Knowledge and Experience: Accountants specialise in tax laws and regulations. They stay up-to-date with changes in tax codes and are well-versed in the nuances of various deductions and credits. It is their job to maintain their expertise and help maximise your eligible tax benefits and minimise errors.


Time Savings: Outsourcing your tax preparation to an accountant frees up your time, allowing you to focus on other important aspects of your life or business. Accountants are trained to efficiently navigate through tax forms and documents, potentially saving you significant time and effort. You didn’t become a business owner to drown in confusing paperwork or systems.


Enhanced Accuracy: Accountants are trained professionals with a keen eye for detail. They are less likely to make errors or overlook critical information when preparing your taxes. Their expertise can provide peace of mind, knowing that your tax return is accurate and in compliance with the latest regulations.


Complex Tax Situations: If your tax situation is complex, such as having multiple sources of income, investments, rental properties, or running a business, hiring an accountant becomes increasingly advantageous.

However, there are potential downsides to hiring an accountant as well:


Cost: Professional tax services come at a cost. It is important to evaluate the potential financial benefits against the fees involved.


Dependency on Others: When you hire an accountant, you relinquish some control over the tax preparation process. While this can be a positive aspect for those seeking assistance and can provide peace of mind that it is accurate, it also means relying on and trusting expertise of the accountant. It’s a good idea to meet with them before jumping in.


Lack of Learning Opportunity: By delegating your tax preparation to an accountant, you may miss out on the opportunity to learn more about tax laws and financial management. Some individuals may value the educational aspect and prefer to actively engage in the tax filing process.


Making the Decision: Factors to Consider

To make an informed decision about whether to file taxes yourself or hire an accountant, consider the following factors:


Complexity of Your Tax Situation: Evaluate the complexity of your financial affairs, including multiple income sources, investments, self-employment, or rental properties. The more complex your situation, the more beneficial it may be to seek professional help.


Time and Effort: Assess your available time and willingness to dedicate it to tax preparation. If you have a busy schedule, find the process overwhelming or leave things till the deadline is looming, then hiring an accountant may be a worthwhile investment.


Financial Considerations: Compare the potential tax savings and benefits you may gain from hiring an accountant against the cost of their services. Consider both short-term and long-term financial implications. An accountant can bring a lot to your business, so thinking about the long-term gain is important.


Risk Tolerance: Determine your comfort level with the potential risks associated with filing taxes yourself. Consider the consequences of errors, the likelihood of being audited, and your ability to handle any resulting penalties or investigations. Not to sound scary, but filing taxes and business related paperwork is something that must be correct.


Personal Preferences: Reflect on your own interest in and ability to handle financial matters. Some individuals enjoy the challenge of preparing their taxes and finds it gives them a good insight into their business, while others prefer to delegate the task to a professional.


It is important to note that even if you decide to file taxes yourself, seeking advice or consultation from an accountant can still be beneficial. They can provide guidance, answer specific questions, or review your tax return before submission to ensure accuracy and compliance.


In conclusion, the decision of whether to file taxes yourself or hire an accountant depends on various factors, including the complexity of your tax situation, available time and effort, financial considerations, risk tolerance, and personal preferences. Assessing these factors can help you make an informed choice that best suits your needs, ensuring that your taxes are prepared accurately and in accordance with applicable laws.

At FiguresUK we’re experts in all things tax, annual returns and everything else from business planning to payroll. We serve Peterborough, Market Deeping and the wider areas, and we pride ourselves in taking the stress out of managing your business finances and helping your business flourish.

Get in contact with us today to find out more about how we work with business owners like you!

Figures UK: Accountants Peterborough - Team: JCJason Cannon
Managing Director and Figures UK Founder

No matter the size of your business, whether you’re a sole trader or a Limited company, when it comes to accounting, it can be a little confusing to say the least.
That’s where we come in. We’re on hand to listen, advise and provide our expert support.

You can find lots more useful information in our blogs below or get in contact with us.

Accounting For You, By Us